3 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin Mireles's avatar

Had to laugh about your idea of funding shutdowns, admitting that an existing program isn’t delivering to expectations or isn’t aligned to the core strength or mission, not because your idea is wrong, but because of how often I hear organizations talk about treating “failure as learning” or “fail fast” or etc. and how few actually reward it.

At FedEx, they talked about treating failure as a learning opportunity, yet no one in my 15 year career they ever got rewarded for “failure”. LOL

At the same time, many programs were shut for failing to deliver on expectations, so this seems like something that is pretty standard in business world, so makes sense that should be encouraged by nonprofits as well.

Yoni Greenbaum's avatar

Kevin, apologies for taking so long to get back to you. This one sat in my notifications longer than it should have, and it deserved a real answer.

You made me laugh too, because you’re right. “Fail fast” gets said in a lot of rooms by people who would never want their own name attached to a failure. Fifteen years at FedEx and nobody ever got rewarded for it tells you everything about how the slogan works in practice.

What strikes me about your point is that business, for all its talk, actually does shut things down. Nobody gets a bonus for it, but a program that isn’t delivering eventually gets cut, and the organization moves on. In the nonprofit world, and especially in nonprofit news, that muscle barely exists. Funders pay for launches. Grant reports are built around continuation. And ending something can feel like telling a funder their money was wasted, so programs that stopped making sense years ago keep limping along because stopping feels riskier than staying mediocre.

That’s really why I landed on the idea of funding shutdowns. Telling people it’s okay to stop doesn’t change much if every incentive still points the other way. If a funder will actually pay for a responsible wind-down, where you document what you learned and move people and money toward what’s working, then stopping starts to look like the smart call it usually is.

I’m curious, though. In all those years at FedEx, did you ever see anyone get close to rewarding a good shutdown? And if not, what do you think it would have taken?

Kevin Mireles's avatar

In the old days, people just got moved around for the most part, but sometimes people got laid off.

Fedex was/is such a giant place, $94B in Fy26, that there is no such thing as single approach to anything.

I worked on the integration of an acquisition, and the marketing organization decided that they didn’t want to waste their time on it, so we all got moved off to other work, while the operating company kept operating despite the fact the company wasn’t going to achieve its goals.

Many projects limped along, while others were killed. It just all depended on circumstances.

Like a lot of things, the answer is it depends, but no one ever got rewarded for failure, that is except Richard Smith, but that was only because he was the Chairman’s son. He truly was an example of rewarding failure. 🙄