3 Comments
User's avatar
Infostack's avatar

Sorry, but none of this takes into account the digital wave that has washed over the journalism landscape, nor the threat from AI that is coming. Digital means 2-way. Digital means global. Digital means long-tail. Digital means increased engagement. All of these can be harnessed to increase ROI locally. The economic model needs to be virtualized to save local journalism (or what is left of it).

Yoni Greenbaum's avatar

I appreciate the perspective, but I think you’re solving a different equation.

Everything you mentioned—the two-way engagement, the long-tail, virtualization, and AI efficiencies—those are tools for changing how a newsroom operates. They are great for cutting production costs and tweaking audience reach. But optimizing your digital operations doesn't solve the core problem of validation.

A hyper-local newsroom can be as lean, virtualized, and AI-optimized as possible, but if it's uncovering corruption in a town of 20,000 people, its primary value isn't "global" or "long-tail." Its value is explicitly local.

The point isn't about the technology we use to deliver the news; it's about the language we use to defend its existence. Whether a story is printed on a press, delivered via a Substack newsletter, or summarized by an AI bot, the fundamental truth remains: if that accountability reporting disappears, the local community pays a direct financial penalty in higher borrowing costs and wasted tax dollars.

We can virtualize the business model all day long, but until we learn to show a local billionaire or a community foundation the actual fiscal ROI of a reporter sitting in a city council meeting, we are still leaving the most powerful argument on the table.

Infostack's avatar

I don't disagree with you. But in a digital world a newspaper needs to think of itself virtually; not as a paper but as a community or diaspora. Understanding, measuring and pointing out the commercial/economic lift is but one (small) aspect of this digital diaspora. More important is how to elevate and capture dialog locally (and globally to the diaspora that has an interest in or connection to that locale), so that the journalism staff (and ultimately the product) is virtualized into this broader diaspora. The platforms have led people to believe they can achieve this, but have failed and made a mess of news (and content). Perhaps there's another way: https://infostack.substack.com/p/taking-power-back-from-the-platforms