
A Quick Disclaimer: Backstory & Strategy is a personal, independent publication. The views, analysis, and commentary expressed here are strictly my own and do not represent the official position, strategy, or endorsement of the American Press Institute, its leadership, or its board. This is my personal space for analyzing the media landscape, testing new frameworks, and thinking out loud.
Years ago, when I worked in local TV news in Philadelphia, I spoke at an all-station meeting held in a studio that happened to face one of our competitors across the street. The room was packed — station leadership, reporters and editors, my digital team, sales and business folks. It was a loud group on a good day.
Then I said something that made it go quiet.
I pointed out the window at the station across the street and said that when it came to digital traffic, they were not the competitor we needed to worry about. I’d pulled the numbers, and if you added up the digital market penetration of all four TV stations in our market — every one of us, combined — it came to about 30 percent of the available audience. Thirty percent. Total.
Which meant 70 percent of the market wasn’t watching any of us. If we stopped obsessing over stealing a point or two of share from the stations across the street and instead went after the people who weren’t watching anybody, we could be number one without ever winning a single ratings book against our “competitors.”
It took a minute to land. Nobody likes hearing that their fiercest rival, the one they measure themselves against every single day, controls maybe eight or nine percent of the actual market. But I watched the math sink in. We had spent years treating each other as the whole game, when the real opportunity was the vast audience none of us had bothered to go get.
I’ve been thinking about that room again lately, because local media is repeating the exact same mistake with creators.
Was this email forwarded to you? If you’d like your own strategic read on journalism and media economics landing in your inbox, subscribe to Backstory & Strategy — it’s free.
Same Room, Wrong Rival
I keep hearing newsroom leaders talk about creators the way my TV colleagues used to talk about the station across the street: competitors, interlopers, or a lesser form of the real thing we do. There’s a familiar anxiety underneath it, the fear that someone else is eating the audience that used to belong to us by default.
Back then, staring out the window blinded us to the 70 percent of the audience we were ignoring. Today there actually is something taking from newsrooms in real time.
It’s just not the creator.
It’s the crawler.
AI companies are scraping newsroom content at scale, training on it, summarizing it, and answering the reader’s question before that reader ever clicks through. No byline. No traffic. No relationship with the person who did the work. Google’s search referral traffic to publishers fell roughly a third over the past year alone, and media leaders surveyed by the Reuters Institute expect referral traffic to nearly halve over the next three years as AI answer engines take over more of the search results page. That’s not competition in any sense my old TV colleagues would recognize — at least the station across the street had to earn a viewer’s attention one broadcast at a time. A bot doesn’t earn anything. It just takes it, at a scale no human competitor ever could.
While newsrooms spend their limited attention treating local creators as the threat, the actual extraction is happening somewhere else entirely: mostly unchallenged, mostly invisible, and legal by default until someone builds the technical and legal fences to stop it.
We’re standing in the studio pointing at the wrong building.
What NewsGrade Actually Tells You
Every newsroom has a website. Almost none of them know what that website looks like to the systems now deciding whether it gets found at all.
The Fixer
I have another way into this, one that’s more literal than a bridge or a trust network. It comes from a job that doesn’t exist without collaboration built into its foundation: the foreign correspondent.
At the start of the second Intifada, I was in Israel and the Palestinian territories, and like every journalist working unfamiliar terrain, I relied on a fixer. A fixer isn’t a translator, or not just a translator. They’re the person who knows which roads are safe that morning, which community leader will actually talk to you, and which questions will get you thrown out of a neighborhood before you’ve asked your first one. No correspondent survives hostile terrain alone. Nobody pretends the fixer is a rival reporter horning in on the story. The fixer is the reason there’s a story at all.
Years later, back home, I ran a team reporting on homeless youth in Philadelphia. I took that same model and turned it inward. We didn’t have a passport-stamped border to cross, but we had one just as real: a community that had no reason to trust a TV crew showing up with cameras and no reason to believe we’d get their story right. So we found our fixers. People embedded in that world who could get us in the door, vouch for us, and tell us when we were about to get something wrong before it aired.
That is the role a creator can play for a newsroom right now, at exactly the moment our digital terrain has grown hostile.
When bots are scraping work and reader attention is getting siphoned off before it ever reaches a homepage, the thing that still cuts through is a person a community already trusts, talking directly to them, on a platform they actually use. A creator with that kind of relationship isn’t competing with a newsroom for what’s left of a shrinking legacy audience. They are one of the few standing bridges to the 70 percent we never reached in the first place.
And this isn’t a one-way street. Newsrooms bring deep reporting power, institutional backing, public-records muscle, and legal vetting that independent creators rarely have on their own. The American Press Institute’s own work with newsroom-creator collaborations has found the same thing from the newsroom side: pair a reporting engine with a creator’s distribution and community trust, and both sides gain ground that neither could capture alone.
You don’t treat your fixer as a rival. You especially don’t treat your fixer as a rival when the ground beneath both of you is shifting. You need every ally you can find.
Building the Alliance
Some of this alliance is already being built, and it’s worth naming so this doesn’t read as wishful thinking. Trusting News and Project C have spent the last year working with local funders and newsrooms on exactly this kind of partnership, including a credibility toolkit built with input from API on how newsrooms can vet and work with creators who share their standards. That same partnership recently grew into a cohort of creator journalists who’ll spend the next several months experimenting with how to signal their own credibility to their audiences.
That’s not a newsroom competing with a creator. That’s an institution treating a creator like a partner worth investing in.
None of this makes the AI problem smaller. If anything, it makes the case for the alliance urgent. When external platforms are extracting journalism’s core value at scale, the last thing that helps is spending our remaining energy fighting the person standing next to us in the same storm.
My old TV colleagues eventually stopped fixating on the station across the street and started thinking about the audience nobody had bothered to reach. Newsrooms have a version of that choice in front of them now. The real threat isn’t the independent voice producing video down the road. It’s the crawler scraping your archives while you argue about the neighbors.
In that fight, a creator isn’t the competition. A creator is a fixer — and in unfamiliar, hostile terrain, a fixer is exactly who you want on your side.
Where is your newsroom looking right now — across the street, at the creators in your feeds, or at the bots crawling through the back door? I’d like to hear how you’re navigating the alliance in the comments.
If this piece was useful, the best way to help it find the newsroom leaders who need it is to restack or share it directly — that does more than any algorithm will.


