A Quick Disclaimer: Backstory & Strategy is a personal, independent publication. The views, analysis, and commentary expressed here are strictly my own and do not represent the official position, strategy, or endorsement of the American Press Institute, its leadership, or its board. This is my personal space for analyzing the media landscape, testing new frameworks, and thinking out loud.
Imagine that after years of working for someone else, you decide to take all of that journalism experience and go out on your own. Your community, like thousands of others, has watched commercial media pull back to the point that coverage is now limited to crime, what TV news likes to call “Big Weather,” and the occasional politician or musician who stops on the way through. So you launch your own news website, and you focus on the issues you think matter: education, development, the arts and the environment.
This is where you’ve lived for years. You know the business owners, the council members, even the mayor. To you, the idea is a slam dunk. You don’t expect to get rich, but you figure there will be enough money to cover the expenses and pay yourself a tidy salary.
But regardless of how much you write, how many days you work and how many weekends you give up, the advertising doesn’t come. Neither do the donations, and neither do the memberships. So you sit at your dining room table, looking at your Google Analytics reports, your editorial calendar and your dwindling savings account, and you wonder whether it’s time to just give up.
I’ve been hearing some version of that story a lot lately, from founders who send me their numbers and ask for an honest read. I trust the instincts that come with more than 30 years in this business, but I trust data even more. That’s a big part of why I built PressViable, to get past “that sounds good” and “those spreadsheets look spot on.” It isn’t an easy conversation either way, and I don’t pretend to be above it. Twenty years ago I left a decent job to start a weekly of my own, and it never made it off the drawing board.
What’s changed for me is where I look first. The business plan matters, and most of the founders I talk with have spent real time on it. But more often than not, I find myself asking about the editorial strategy instead. “People won’t pay for local news” is an understandable refrain, and after enough late nights with a spreadsheet, it starts to feel like a law of nature. I’ve looked at enough communities to believe it usually isn’t the problem, which means the answer may be even harder to hear.
People may well be willing to pay. Just not for what you’re providing.
Backstory & Strategy is free, and it’s built for the people building, running and funding local news. If that’s you, subscribe and get the hard calls, explained by someone who’s made them, in your inbox.
The wrong question
When a founder hits that wall, the question tends to come out the same way. At what point do you look at the market and accept that this community just isn’t going to support local news?
It’s an honest question, and sometimes the honest answer is yes. There are places where the households, the businesses and the local giving simply can’t carry a reporter, no matter what that reporter covers. When I look at the data on communities like that, the pattern is usually the same. They lack more than a business base; they lack a philanthropic base too. With few advertisers and no foundations to lean on, nearly the entire weight of funding a news operation falls on households.
But in a lot of the cases I see, the question itself is the problem. It treats a product decision as a verdict on the town. It assumes “local news” is one thing that a community either supports or doesn’t, when it’s really a category, the same way “restaurant” is a category. A town that won’t support one version of it may be perfectly happy to support another.
Mission Local in San Francisco is a good illustration. When it joined LION Publishers’ Sustainability 360 program, the team came in with one question: how do we grow our advertising revenue? Coaching turned that into a bigger conversation about what kind of newsroom Mission Local wanted to be. Among other things, an outlet known for hyperlocal neighborhood reporting had started covering city-wide issues without a formal strategy for it. What looked like a revenue question turned out to be an identity question first.
That reflex is everywhere, and I understand it. When the money doesn’t come, the instinct is to add another way to collect it: launch a membership tier, host an event, apply for a grant. The advice founders get points the same direction. When LION surveyed more than 300 independent newsrooms in 2025, the story was all about the revenue mix, with philanthropy overtaking advertising as the most common stream and one in three newsrooms earning money from events. None of that is wrong. Diversifying revenue is sound practice. But too often founders and operators treat a stalled business as a revenue diversification problem, and not often enough as a product problem. Five ways to pay for something people don’t want badly enough is still zero. The harder question comes first: is what you’re offering something this community wants to buy?
It isn’t that nobody has made the product case. Frameworks like Jobs to Be Done and the User Needs model have been pushing newsrooms for years to start from what readers actually need, and plenty of larger newsrooms have taken that to heart. But by the time the advice reaches a solo founder at a dining room table, what usually arrives is the revenue toolkit. The product question gets skipped right at the moment it matters most.
You wouldn’t open a steakhouse in a neighborhood known for its community gardens and its strong vegetarian streak. And if you did, and it closed, you wouldn’t walk away convinced that people there don’t eat out. You’d conclude, correctly, that they didn’t want what you were serving.
Reach isn’t demand
Most of the founders I talk with aren’t short on audience. They have the pageviews, the newsletter opens, the shares, and a steady stream of “love what you’re doing” at the coffee shop and the farmers market. That’s real, and it isn’t nothing. But it measures interest, not hunger. People will read, share and compliment something for years without ever reaching for their wallet, the same way they’ll stroll a market sampling everything and leave with one jar of honey.
It’s worth being precise about which revenue isn’t showing up, because the three streams don’t fail for the same reason. Advertising is its own problem. It has as much to do with scale, and with where local businesses now spend their marketing dollars, as it does with anything on your homepage, and that’s a column for another day.
Memberships and donations are different. That’s where the menu shows. People give to local news for reasons that are a lot more specific than civic duty: because it’s useful to them every week, because it says something about who they are, or because it makes them feel part of something. Civic duty gets some people to the checkout page, but it isn’t what gets most of them there. If your coverage is admirable but optional, readers will admire it and treat it as optional.
The research points the same way, even if some of it is getting old. In 2017 the Media Insight Project, a collaboration of the American Press Institute, where I work, and AP-NORC, asked people who don’t pay for news why they don’t. The most common answer, from about half of them, was that there’s plenty of free news around. But 41 percent said they weren’t interested enough to pay for it, well ahead of the 24 percent who said it cost too much. Later that year, the same project surveyed more than 4,000 recent newspaper subscribers: 60 percent said they wanted access to local news, and 31 percent cited supporting local journalism. And when Northwestern’s Medill Local News Initiative studied subscriber datafrom the Chicago Tribune, the San Francisco Chronicle and the Indianapolis Star, how often someone came back, not how many stories they read or how long they stayed, was the single biggest predictor of whether they kept paying. What built that habit was local coverage the paper owned and nobody else had.
At Philly.com, we ran Haiku Wednesdays. Every Wednesday at lunchtime, readers competed in a haiku contest, posting their poems and hoping to win a prize or two. It drove people to the website, and while they were there, they read our journalism too. Nobody in the newsroom would have called a haiku contest our most important work. But it gave people a reason to come back every week, and that habit carried the rest of what we published along with it.
What a pivot actually looks like
Restaurants change their menus all the time, and nobody accuses them of selling out. They add a lunch special when the office park down the road fills up, drop the dish nobody orders, adjust prices, open for brunch on Sundays. The kitchen stays the same and so do the cook’s standards. What changes is the fit between what’s on offer and who’s walking through the door.
Journalism isn’t immune to the pivot, and it shouldn’t want to be. In a newsroom, a pivot can mean a handful of different things, and most of them leave the mission intact:
What you cover. Covering the same beat at the level where people actually make decisions. In education, that means redistricting, budgets and program cuts explained for the families they affect, not principal profiles and graduation lists.
How you package it. The same reporting delivered as a Monday briefing, a text alert or a practical guide rather than a long feature nobody has time for.
Who you sell to. A development beat may be worth more to the people who build, buy and lend in a town than it is to a general reader, and they may be willing to pay accordingly.
What you charge, and for what. A membership that gets someone something on day one is a different offer than a donation button.
I’ve been through a pivot like this myself. At Lehigh Valley Public Media, we realized people wanted the kind of content we were providing on PBS39 News Tonight, just not on the platform or the schedule we were providing it. So we made a total pivot. We left TV and moved to a digital product, LehighValleyNews.com, where people could get much of the same content when and where they wanted it, instead of having to turn on their TV at 7 or 11 p.m. The menu was right; the way we served it wasn’t.
Magazines have been doing this out in the open for decades. Texas Monthly has been ranking the state’s barbecue joints since its first year, 1973. In 2013 it went a step further and made Daniel Vaughn what he has described as the nation’s first full-time barbecue editor. Today barbecue is a franchise of its own there, with the Top 50 list, a festival, a paid BBQ Club and a public television special. The same magazine still covers Texas politics. Taking brisket seriously didn’t cost Texas Monthly its credibility. It found something its readers would line up for, and it built around it.
The part that costs something
Here’s the objection, and it’s a fair one to raise. If “pivot” just means chasing whatever sells, you end up with a site full of restaurant openings and Friday night scores, and nobody sitting at the planning commission. Underneath that objection is an assumption: the coverage a community needs most is the coverage it’s least willing to pay for.
I don’t buy that assumption, at least not nearly as often as we tell ourselves. Take schools. In a lot of the communities I’ve looked at, people will pay for education coverage. What they won’t pay for is the version most newsrooms serve up: principal profiles, graduation lists and lunch menus. The coverage that has a real shot is the kind that helps a parent make a decision or understand a cost. Why the district is redrawing attendance lines. What next year’s budget means for class sizes in their kid’s building, or for their tax bill. Why a program got cut, and who made the call. That’s accountability reporting, aimed at a question the reader already has rather than one the newsroom thinks they ought to have.
The research backs that instinct more than the industry’s fixation on revenue streams would suggest. In the same 2017 Media Insight Project survey, the No. 1 reason subscribers gave for paying, cited by more than 4 in 10, was that the publication excels at covering topics they care about. Not the mission, not the discount. The coverage.
In the late 1990s at the North Jersey Herald & News, we wrote about families in Passaic County struggling to keep their children focused on school while they walked to and from it on streets plagued by gangs and drug dealing. That was education coverage every bit as much as a test-score story, and it was about the thing those parents actually lay awake worrying about.
In other words, the pivot usually happens inside the beat, not away from it. Most founders don’t need to stop covering education, development or the environment. They need to stop covering them the way a press release would.
There’s a bigger shift underneath this, and it’s about how a community sees you. Most of us came up as storytellers, and we still measure ourselves by the story: the feature, the narrative, the piece that wins the award. Storytelling can absolutely sell at national or statewide scale, where the audience is big enough to carry it. Texas Monthly is proof of that. But in a town of 30,000, the audience for a beautiful feature is rarely big enough to pay anyone’s salary, and readers can admire a local storyteller for years without ever paying one. A utility is different. It’s something people rely on, the way they rely on the water coming out of the tap, and they notice right away when it’s gone.
Not all utility is worth building a business on, though. “When is the zoning hearing” is something a town website, a Facebook group or, increasingly, an AI answer will hand people for free. “What the new attendance map means for your street” is much harder to replace, because it takes someone who knows the street. That’s the utility that makes a newsroom part of how a town actually runs, and it’s a very different relationship from being the outlet that writes good stories about the town. It’s also a much easier one to charge for.
And I’d push back, gently, on the idea that any of this only works where people have money to spare. Even in communities with very little disposable income, people pay for the things they rely on. The questions are what, and how much. A newsroom that prices like a national magazine in a town where people count every dollar has a pricing problem, not proof that nobody will pay. Sometimes the right membership is a few dollars a month. Sometimes the public-good work in a struggling market really does need a funder. Either way, that’s a conclusion to reach with evidence, not an assumption to start from.
I made the editorial half of this argument in June, in The Job We Haven’t Been Doing: most journalism is built just in case, while utility journalism is built just in time. This is the business half. A newsroom that shows up at the moment people need it is a newsroom people have a reason to pay.
Some work genuinely won’t pay for itself, and for that part the old newspaper bargain still has something to teach. Advertising once paid most of the bills, about 80 percent of revenue by the industry’s old rule of thumb, and that money underwrote a statehouse bureau that very few readers bought the paper for. The modern version might be a funder underwriting the six-month investigation while readers pay for the coverage they use every week, with each knowing exactly what it’s paying for. Some of this work may well be a public good the market won’t fund by itself. But that’s the exception to plan for, not the explanation for a menu nobody is ordering from.
The real risk runs the other way: a pivot that never comes back around. When I worked in TV, I heard about a station with a gorgeous, even breathtaking, facility. It was such a beautiful building that the station started renting it out for weddings, bar mitzvahs and quinceañeras, and after a while it was bringing in more money from the rentals than from its core business. You could read that as a success story, and in one sense it was, because the community was telling the station exactly what it would pay for. It just wasn’t the news. A menu change only counts as a pivot if journalism is still what comes out of the kitchen. Past that point, you’re running a different business that happens to have a newsroom attached.
There’s a second way to get this wrong, and the industry ran that experiment at scale less than a decade ago. During the “pivot to video” in 2017, outlets like Mic and Vocativ cut writers to chase the video ad dollars that the platforms seemed to promise. These were already struggling companies, and the pivot didn’t save them. By comScore’s count, Mic went from 17.5 million visitors in August 2016 to 6.6 million a year later. Vocativ let go of its entire newsroom. In November 2018, after Facebook canceled a video deal, Mic laid off most of its staff and was sold to Bustle for a reported sum under $5 million. They changed the menu, but they changed it for the platform rather than for the people eating. A pivot has to point toward whoever is actually paying you.
The Menu Test
So how do you pivot without lying to yourself? Before you change a thing, I’d sit with five questions, ideally with someone who doesn’t love your coverage as much as you do.
What does this community already pay for? Not news, necessarily. A high school sports stream, a church bulletin with paid ads, a neighborhood Facebook group with sponsors, the community events calendar, paid obituaries, the weekly shopper that still lands in driveways. Money already moving in a category is the best evidence of demand you’re going to get.
What has anyone paid you for, even a little? The one-time gift after a particular story, the sponsor who stuck with one section, the newsletter people kept forwarding. Those are your menu’s best sellers. Read them like a sales report, not a pat on the back.
What does a paying reader get on day one? If the honest answer is “the satisfaction of supporting local journalism,” you have a donation pitch, not a product.
Who pays for the part that won’t sell? Name it before you change anything. If the answer is “nobody yet,” that’s your fundraising plan, not a footnote.
What comes off the menu? A pivot that only adds things is just more work for the same tired kitchen. I made a version of this case in The Sunset List: stopping something is how you make room for the work you actually want to do.
If you know a founder sitting at that dining room table right now, send this to them. These five questions are easier to answer with someone else in the room.
Back at the dining room table
Go back to that founder at the dining room table, with the analytics open and the savings account dwindling. The question on their mind is whether to give up. I’d gently suggest a different one: which version of this would someone in my town actually pay for, and can I live with making it?
Sometimes the answer really is no. Either the market isn’t there, or the version that would sell isn’t one you’re willing to run, and walking away from that is a legitimate decision, not a failure of nerve.
But more often than founders expect, the community didn’t reject local news. It passed on the menu. That’s a different problem, and a far more fixable one, as long as you’re willing to change what comes out of the kitchen.
Now I want to hear from you. Have you changed your menu, or watched a newsroom that should have? What has your community actually been willing to pay for? Tell me in the comments. I read every one.


