A Quick Disclaimer: Backstory & Strategy is a personal, independent publication. The views, analysis, and commentary expressed here are strictly my own and do not represent the official position, strategy, or endorsement of the American Press Institute, its leadership, or its board. This is my personal space for analyzing the media landscape, testing new frameworks, and thinking out loud.
I’ve sat in this meeting more times than I can count.
You walk a potential funder through the work. The investigation that actually moved something at City Hall. The coverage that nobody else in the market is doing. The newsletter people genuinely open, the community events that fill a room, the revenue mix you’ve spent years making a little less fragile. It’s a good conversation. They’re nodding. Somebody says, “impressive.”
Then they lean back and ask the question.
“But what about...”
What about climate? What about housing? What about the school board in the next county over that nobody’s covering?
Every one of those questions is fair, and every gap they name is real. But every one of them, taken seriously, means building a beat you don’t have the people to do well, or pulling someone off the work you just spent forty minutes proving matters.
Nobody in that room is doing anything wrong. The funder wants to help. The newsroom leader wants the money and, honestly, would love to cover climate too. So the answer is almost always some version of yes. The newsroom takes on the beat, and with it a new set of reports, a new set of metrics, and one more grant to track, all landing on the same handful of leaders who run the core work. A newsroom that was finally getting good at a few things goes back to being adequate at many.
Philanthropy’s usual answer to this problem is flexible money: unrestricted, multiyear, general operating support. That helps, and I’ll get to the evidence. But it doesn’t fix this, because the problem isn’t how the money is restricted. It’s the question that decides where the money goes. A funder can write the most flexible check in the world and still choose who gets it, and how much, by asking what’s missing. This piece is about changing that question, and about a specific grant mechanism, a sunset grant, that would prove a funder means it.
Pull up a stool. Backstory & Strategy is an independent look at media economics, leadership, and the connective tissue between them. If you want clear-eyed analysis that cuts through the industry jargon, subscribe to get every post in your inbox. It’s free.
The needs map
There’s a name for what happens in that moment, and it comes from community development, not journalism.
In 1993, John Kretzmann and John McKnight of Northwestern University published Building Communities from the Inside Out. Their argument was that most outside help arrives carrying a “needs map,” a picture of a neighborhood drawn entirely from what it lacks. Foundations and the United Way, they noted, built much of their funding on exactly that kind of problem-oriented survey.
The trouble with a needs map isn’t that it’s wrong. It’s that it’s incomplete in a way that shapes everything downstream. If all you can see is the list of deficits, the only move left is to fill them, one outside resource at a time. Kretzmann and McKnight argued that kind of strategy could guarantee survival but never real development. Their alternative, which they called asset-based community development, starts with a different question: what’s already here that we can build on?
“But what about...” is a needs map drawn in real time. In that moment, the funder isn’t really looking at the newsroom. They’re looking at the empty space around it.
Flexible money didn’t fix it
For twenty years, the reform agenda in philanthropy has been about the form of the money. Bridgespan’s 2009 “Nonprofit Starvation Cycle” showed how funders’ unrealistic expectations about overhead push nonprofits to do “more and more with less and less.” The fix everyone converged on was general operating support, and funders mostly agree with it. When the Center for Effective Philanthropy surveyed foundation leaders, 58 percent said they provide some multiyear general operating support, though only 11 percent of those give it to more than half their grantees, and the researchers found no common barrier holding them back.
Journalism has heard the same warning from inside. Sue Cross, when she led the Institute for Nonprofit News, told a room of journalism funders that newsrooms can’t live on project grants alone, and that project money which ignores core infrastructure can end up weakening the newsrooms it means to help.
And the field has made real progress. Press Forward’s first open call put $20 million into 205 small newsrooms, mostly as $100,000 in unrestricted general operating support over two years. That’s exactly the kind of money the reform agenda asked for, and I’d like to see a lot more of it.
But look at what the call was named: Closing Local Coverage Gaps. Its goal was making sure local coverage meets the needs of communities that aren’t adequately served. To be fair, it funded newsrooms already doing that original reporting, which is closer to an asset bet than most grantmaking gets. The money came with no strings. The frame that organized it was still a needs map. And frames write applications. A newsroom answering a call named for gaps instinctively leads with the void it could fill, not the anchor it already is, and the pitch that wins is the one that sounds most like something new.
That’s the distinction the field keeps collapsing. Restricted versus unrestricted is a question about how money moves. Needs versus assets is a question about why it moves at all. You can fix the first and leave the second completely intact, and a newsroom that wins an unrestricted “gap” grant still learns the same lesson: the way to get funded is to promise something you aren’t doing yet.
Know a program officer, board member, or newsroom leader who has lived the “but what about” moment? Forward this, or drop it in the Slack channel where this conversation is already happening.
What depth buys
When a funder does invest in an organization’s existing strength, the evidence is encouraging. Ford’s BUILD program put $1 billion over five years into flexible, multiyear support aimed at strengthening organizations themselves. Its 2025 longitudinal evaluation found positive effects on resilience and mission impact, and the path between them worked like a loop: stronger organizations attracted more investment and took on bigger opportunities, which made them stronger still. Depth didn’t come at the expense of growth. It’s what made the growth hold. Ford paid for its own evaluation, and the grantees weren’t newsrooms, but nothing about that mechanism is unique to their sector.
MacArthur ran a purer version. From 2006 to 2016, its Award for Creative and Effective Institutions made 102 grants, $67 million in all, to existing grantees whose work was already exceptional, mostly for reserves and financial health. Nobody could apply. By the foundation’s own account the grants were highly useful, and it ended the program anyway as it narrowed its strategy around a few Big Bets.
That’s the cautionary tale. Programs that keep good institutions healthy rarely die from bad results. They die from strategic churn, when the quiet work of keeping strong organizations strong stops looking like a strategy. Which is why the fix can’t just be a better attitude in the room. It has to be something a funder can put in a budget.
We say yes, too
Newsroom leaders don’t get to sit this one out. Every “but what about” gets an answer, and we’re the ones who give it.
We say yes because the money is real and the gap is real, and because turning down a funder feels like a luxury nobody in local news can afford. It doesn’t help that the gap a funder names is often its own priority. Many journalism funders also do policy work in the same areas they fund coverage of. But every yes teaches funders that the way to help is to offer something new. If newsrooms never walk into that meeting with a clear account of what they’re best at, and what it would take to make it undeniable, funders will keep filling the silence with gaps.
So what follows isn’t only a funder practice. It only works if newsroom leaders are willing to ask for it.
Newsroom leaders: what’s the “but what about” you said yes to and wish you hadn’t? Tell me in the comments. I read every one.
The questions an asset-based funder asks
So what would it look like to walk into that meeting with an asset map instead of a needs map? Mostly, it comes down to which questions get asked first.
What is this newsroom already known for? Not what it covers. What the community comes to it for, and would notice the week it disappeared.
What would it take to make that undeniable? Maybe it’s better data access, or time for longer projects, or a second editor so the best reporter isn’t also the copy desk. Maybe it’s a format that reaches people who will never read a 3,000-word story.
What is that strength costing them right now? Excellent work running on thin infrastructure is a prototype that never got its upgrade, and prototypes break.
Who else in the ecosystem is better placed to fill the gap? If climate coverage really is missing, the answer might be a collaborative, a partnership, or a different grantee entirely. It doesn’t have to be this newsroom’s next beat.
That last one matters most. “But what about...” quietly assumes that every gap in a community’s information belongs to whichever newsroom happens to be sitting across the table. A funder who thinks at the level of the whole ecosystem can fill those gaps without hollowing out the organizations that are already working.
A proposal: the sunset grant
Here’s something any funder could pilot next cycle. Call it a sunset grant.
A newsroom names one program, beat, product, or event it would retire if it could afford to. Maybe it’s the legacy section, the newsletter almost nobody opens, or the annual event that eats a month of staff time. The funder covers whatever revenue or relationships that program carries for two years, plus the cost of the transition. In exchange, the newsroom retires it and moves those hours into the work it already does best.
A few design principles keep it honest:
The newsroom picks what to cut, not the funder. Anything else turns subtraction into a new kind of restriction.
The application starts with the strength. The question isn’t “what will you start?” It’s “what’s working, and what is it starving for?”
Two years, with a plan for year three. The grant buys time for the core work, now with full staff attention behind it, to replace the retired program’s revenue through deeper audience loyalty, membership, or sponsorship. It isn’t a permanent subsidy.
Success is measured on the core work, not the cut. Did the strongest work get deeper, more used, more trusted? That’s measurable: retention on that coverage, citations by other outlets, the community or policy outcomes the newsroom already tracks, the staff hours actually freed. It’s a narrower question than “what was your total impact?”, which is exactly why it can be answered.
For funders who aren’t ready for that, there’s a lighter version. Open every renewal conversation with an asset review before anyone mentions a gap: what is this newsroom known for, what would make it undeniable, and what should it stop doing? Write the answers down, and fund against them.
As far as I can tell, almost nobody in journalism philanthropy funds subtraction on purpose. In nonprofit news, missions only ever seem to expand, partly because retiring anything feels like admitting failure in front of the people who paid for it. A funder willing to pay a newsroom to do less, better, would be offering a kind of permission nobody else in that newsroom’s world can give.
Before the next beat
None of this means gaps don’t matter. Communities lose something when nobody covers the housing authority or the water board. But those gaps belong to the ecosystem, not to whichever newsroom happens to be across the table, and an ecosystem fills them best when the newsrooms already in it are strong enough to rely on.
A needs map on its own has a predictable outcome. Newsrooms get wider and thinner, and the work that earned a funder’s attention gets a little worse every year, in meetings where everyone was trying to help.
So the next time you’re across the table from a newsroom that has just walked you through its best work, hold the “but what about” for one more question. Ask what it would take to make that work undeniable. Then fund the answer, even if the answer is less.
Related: The 160x Efficiency Play: Why Distribution is the Real Product
Join the conversation. Would your newsroom take a sunset grant, and what would you retire first? If you’re a funder who would pilot one, or already funds something like it, I want to hear from you. Leave a comment or reply to this email.



Had to laugh about your idea of funding shutdowns, admitting that an existing program isn’t delivering to expectations or isn’t aligned to the core strength or mission, not because your idea is wrong, but because of how often I hear organizations talk about treating “failure as learning” or “fail fast” or etc. and how few actually reward it.
At FedEx, they talked about treating failure as a learning opportunity, yet no one in my 15 year career they ever got rewarded for “failure”. LOL
At the same time, many programs were shut for failing to deliver on expectations, so this seems like something that is pretty standard in business world, so makes sense that should be encouraged by nonprofits as well.