
When I worked in the Lehigh Valley for seven years, I saw one local cultural juggernaut execute a strategy newsrooms can’t seem to learn from. That juggernaut was ArtsQuest. Nestled into Bethlehem, PA is a non-profit arts and culture complex affectionately known as SteelStacks. It’s a 10-acre blast of cultural offerings erected directly on the ground once inhabited by the Bethlehem Steel blast furnaces. They host upwards of 4,000 performances, exhibits, and festivals each year, from intimate gallery exhibitions and comedy nights to regional drawcards like Christkindlmarkt and Musikfest, a 10-day summer jubilee that brings over 1 million attendees to the Valley each year.
But what sets ArtsQuest apart isn’t the size of their reach; it’s how closely they measure and track their economic output. Just scan their annual reports: ArtsQuest’s programming produced a record $192.7 million in economic impact to the region in 2025 while supporting 1,533 full-time equivalent jobs. When they report on Musikfest or Christkindlmarkt, they talk about total hotel nights booked in the area, restaurant transactions, and small business profits. They counted feet at the door, and then they kept counting what those feet spent.
What makes this convincing isn’t the headline number, it’s the trend line behind it. ArtsQuest’s reported economic impact has climbed from $35.8 million in 2010 to $192.7 million in 2025, including a recovery from pandemic-era lows of $116 million in 2018 and $136 million in 2019. That’s sixteen years of an arts nonprofit tracking its own economic case the way a publicly traded company tracks quarterly earnings. Nobody ran that study once and put it on a shelf.
Backstory & Strategy is a personal, independent publication. The views, analysis, and commentary expressed here are strictly my own and do not represent the official position, strategy, or endorsement of the American Press Institute, its leadership, or its board. This is my personal space for analyzing the media landscape, testing new frameworks, and thinking out loud.
This practice isn’t unique to ArtsQuest. Museums, theaters, and arts non-profits all over the country have been justifying their budgets to cities and philanthropists with cold hard numbers for decades now. There was a time, however, when they didn’t. Arts organizations and institutions used to exclusively argue for intrinsic value. The arts were presented as necessary for the soul, without a care for currency. The administrative tide turned when funding for the arts was threatened by budget cuts amid the political and economic collapses of the late 80s and early 90s. To defend their programs, museums and organizations became acutely aware of their economic impact. Leaders in arts advocacy began collating fiscal data, and in 1994 Americans for the Arts published its first Arts & Economic Prosperity study. These expensive investigations changed the conversation from “art is good” to “look at how much business the art brought to restaurants and hotels.”
Why won’t news organizations do the same?
Traditionally, the answer is because we’re exhausted and stuck in our ways. Journalism operated on a commercial advertising revenue model for over 150 years. Publishers sold readers to advertisers, while editors fretted about maintaining a church-and-state divide between the newsroom and business desk. Journalists saw themselves as watchdogs, not wealth generators. Pitching our value based on our own economic impact felt gauche, too close to an advertorial.
Now, newsrooms operate in Fight Club mode. Most organizations are so understaffed that publishers hear “measure your economic impact” and immediately think of hiring Ph.D. economists or starting billion-dollar studies. It’s unsustainable.
The Empty Aisle: Why Journalism's Biggest Beat Doesn't Exist
The thing that determines how people vote is also the thing they most need help navigating day to day. And almost no one in the news is covering it that way.
Some newsrooms have figured out half of this equation. Consider your Texas Tribunes and NHPRs of the world. When it comes time to sell their flagship events to corporations and civic leaders, they run a straight copy-and-paste of the ArtsQuest playbook. They can point to millions of dollars’ worth of hotel room blocks and downtown restaurant traffic as quantifiable dollars brought into the city by their programming. It works. Sponsors write checks because the math is right there in the deck.
But when festival season ends and the newsroom gets back to core reporting, the math disappears. We revert to the art argument and start spending the outdated currency of civic responsibility again. “Support journalism because democracy dies in darkness.” “A city needs civic engagement to keep its government accountable.” That’s the real inconsistency worth sitting with: the same organization that will hand a sponsor a spreadsheet of hotel nights for a three-day festival won’t hand a foundation a spreadsheet for the watchdog reporting it does the other 362 days of the year. We’ve decided events are commerce and journalism is virtue, and we only apply the rigorous argument to the part of the business that was never in danger of folding.
Those civic messages are true. But they carry little weight with your garden-variety billionaire or a corporate donor looking for measurable returns. While we’ve been yelling about how journalism improves the world from our pulpit of public good, arts and cultural organizations have been quietly winning this argument on the street by calculating actual ROI.
Journalism adds enormous economic value to municipalities. We just don’t like to take credit for it. If a reporter closes a fraud scheme at city hall, local businesses just got protected from losing millions of dollars. Instead of messaging how your work adds dollars to a city, we say it “protects” dollars.
There is a growing contingent in media that knows this argument can be measured, and the data is starting to stack up. The clearest single data point: a journalism “news desert premium,” updated by Rebuild Local News this June, costs taxpayers across America $1.1 billion each year in unnecessary interest. That number exists because researchers at the University of Illinois Chicago and Notre Dame have been studying what happens to local government finances when a newspaper closes up shop. It’s bad. Local governments lose their policing financial watchdog and watch their borrowing rates climb by 5 to 11 basis points three years down the line. Without journalists reviewing city council budgets, lenders charge more on loans because they perceive risk.
A NOTE FROM OUR SPONSOR
Backstory & Strategy is supported by Editorial Style — apparel for people who believe the press matters. If you work in journalism, support it, or just refuse to apologize for caring about it, Editorial Style was built for you. Use code BACKSTORY at checkout for 15% off your first order.
The rest of the field is catching up to that logic from different angles. MOME’s 2022 study found NYC publishers generated $34 billion in economic output back in 2020, valuating publishers and digital newsrooms the same way a film production or theater contract would be. The Local Media Consortium, which represents over 5,000 local newsrooms across North America, has published an annual “Member Economic Impact Report” since 2021; their July 2023 report broke down how participating in their shared services model saved member publishers $55 million in aggregate. And academia is now building the permanent infrastructure for this kind of accounting: the Local News Impact Consortium, a coalition of researchers from six universities including Rutgers, Missouri, and Northwestern, formed in 2024, is actively building an “Operational Toolkit” for newsrooms and community foundations and recruiting research assistants to quantify the economic impact of local news.
Throw in proven increases to municipal spending, reckless corporate violations, and basic inefficiencies without local media acting as a moderator, and the fiscal case for news suddenly becomes priceless.
Asking newsrooms to start internalizing and pitching their economic value is not asking you to hire more researchers or turn every reporter into an accountant. Newsrooms don’t need additional studies. We need a framework for changing the conversation around what we already do. Any news organization, regardless of size, can approach this messaging in one of three ways:
1. Macro: Lean On Existing Studies
Small organizations do not need to hire a team of Pulitzer winners to start proving economic value. Large-scale economic studies have already proven the impact of local news; you just have to apply them locally when talking to foundations or donors. Newsrooms can say: “Studies have proven that when a local newspaper closes, local governments pay millions more in interest on bonds. Your $100,000 contribution to our local government watchdog is an insurance policy that protects local taxpayers from losing $300,000.”
2. Micro: Calculate the “Cost of the Story”
Newsrooms can also attach dollar figures to specific stories. If your reporters dig up a corrupt municipal contract worth millions, highlight the cost: “We stopped a $4 million garbage removal contract from being awarded to the son-in-law of a city hall staffer.” If a local watchdog stops a proposed tax hike, do the math on household savings: “Thanks to our coverage of the buried budget surplus, we stopped a property tax hike that would’ve cost the median family in this town $250.”
3. Additive: Use Your Media Multiplier
If you run events, track your footprint. How many people attended your mayoral debate? Did you sell tickets? Are there local vendors, bartenders, caterers, venues, you can tally up? Does your organization sell local goods or highlight small businesses on your site? When you publish a local business profile, follow up with them a month later: did your sales increase because of us? Anecdotally collecting those quotes can help you establish your media multiplier.
What is the economic cost when news desert growth goes unchecked? Museums and cultural institutions didn’t change their shows or programming to attract more visitors; they started measuring feet at the door. Local news organizations don’t need to change their reporting. But we do need to start asking one question at the end of every story. What does this corrupt contract cost the taxpayer? How much will those lowered business taxes save you over time?
Newsrooms can continue to preach the gospel about how vital journalism is to democracy, but it’s time we start telling the neighbors how that journalism protects their wallets too. We already know how to count the house for one weekend in August. It’s time we counted it the other fifty-one weeks as well.
If this framework is useful to you, the best thing you can do is steal it. Take the Macro, Micro, or Additive approach to your next board meeting, donor pitch, or sponsor deck, and see what happens when you stop arguing for journalism’s soul and start arguing for its math.
If you run a newsroom that’s already doing this well, or doing it badly, I want to hear about it. Drop it in the comments; I read every one, and I’m always looking for the next example to steal back.
And if you haven’t subscribed yet, Backstory & Strategy comes out when there’s something worth saying, not on a schedule designed to hit your inbox quota. Subscribe to get the next one when it’s ready.
Know an editor, publisher, or board member who’s still pitching civic virtue to a donor who wants ROI? Forward this to them. It might be a more useful conversation starter than another grant application.



Sorry, but none of this takes into account the digital wave that has washed over the journalism landscape, nor the threat from AI that is coming. Digital means 2-way. Digital means global. Digital means long-tail. Digital means increased engagement. All of these can be harnessed to increase ROI locally. The economic model needs to be virtualized to save local journalism (or what is left of it).